2026/11/03

He is Duncan MacLeod, the Highlander born in 1592 in the Highlands of Scottland and he is still alive. He is Immortal. For 400 years, he's been a warrior, a lover, a wanderer. Constantly facing other Immortals in combat to the death. The winner takes his enemies’ head, and with it his power. I am a Watcher, part of a secret society of men and women who observe and record but never interfere. We know the truth about Immortals. In the end, there can be only one. May it be Duncan MacLeod, the Highlander.

I finished watching season five of Highlander, which took me about 3.5 months. Reason why this takes so long is because I watch it with my wife. She can handle watching one or two episodes per week only, but I am just happy I don’t have to watch it on my own with the few hours of rewatch possibilities I have within a day.

To me season five is one of the strongest seasons yet, my wife however, felt that the last bunch of episodes were not as strong as the first part of season five. To me, it has one real dud, episode 17, “The Modern Prometheus”, but overall, I enjoyed it and of course the two-parter “Comes a Horseman” and “Revelation 6:8” is the very best this season has to offer. Most likely in my Top 10, or even Top 5 of all Highlander episodes, where we get very uncomfortable with Methos, with these Immortal buddies murdering, destroying villages, raping women and what not.



For the most part the 5th season is a continuation of what followed before it, but there are some differences this season: It is a somewhat darker and more reflective season for Duncan MacLeod, with the series increasingly exploring the psychological and emotional consequences of his centuries-long life as an Immortal. Increasingly Duncan seems to be having problems going through life having to chop other Immortals’ heads off. He himself never goes looking to kill other Immortals, usually they come to him because they threaten Duncan’s friends or someone from his past comes looking for him. He’d rather not kill any other Immortal, only when he has no choice or when this other Immortal deserves this according to his moral code.

So, season five does feel different than the earlier seasons, a more mature Highlander. The early seasons were mostly structured around encountering another Immortal, we learn their story, how they met in the past and such, and then the inevitable Quickening. While in season five this is still present, but something is added to the mix, we get to learn more about why Immortals behave the way they do and what centuries of being alive do to a person's character. There is an episode “Little Thin God” where an Immortal has appointed himself as God, because he cannot die in a normal way. Makes you think how many times this would have happened before with Immortals, when they discover they can manipulate people like this, especially when faith or religion is involved.

Several season five episodes look at questions as:

  • What happens when an Immortal gets tired of living?
  • How can someone be morally good after centuries of killing other Immortals?
  • Should Immortals interfere / interact with mortal people?
  • Can an Immortal live a normal life, can he or she ever really escape his or her past?
  • Is the prize of “There can only be one” worth the enormous sacrifices?


Season five feels more character-driven and it has become more morally complex than most of the earlier seasons, although I believe this is also an evolution from season to season. Season five does have a slightly different feel to it, a bit darker, especially with episodes like “Prophecy”, “The End of Innocence”, “Haunted”, “Little Thin God”, “The Messenger”, “The Valkyrie”, “The famous Two-parter”, “Forgive Us Our Trespasses” and of course the season finale “Archangel”.

More than any other season, Duncan’s friends become a bigger part of his life, Amanda keeps coming back, they love each other, but somehow, they never seem to want to commit to a relationship. Although I do like Amanda a lot, she also annoyed me at times, not sure how to explain it, most likely because of certain character traits. She does have a good heart, as said, she loves Duncan and tries to help but it amazes me how she got as old as she is, because she is a terrible swordfighter, it is horrible to watch to be honest.

Methos has become a dear friend to Duncan, even after what happened with the two-parter “Comes a Horseman” and “Revelation 6:8”, but it does damage his relationship with Duncan. I am fond of the Methos character, I don’t think I would have liked him when he was one of the Horsemen, but Peter Wingfield does such a great job. Methos is not like the Highlander, he is a pragmatist, usually he looks out for himself, he does not want to risk his life saving others, not like Duncan. Of course, Duncan does influence him a bit, but it goes no further than the immediate circle of people he cares for: Mac, Joe, Richie and Amanda. In episode 16 “Forgive Us Our Trespasses”, we see Methos in a swordfight, longer than usual and more impressive than usual, really enjoyed it, seeing him do the Highlander thing!

And Joe, for a while after the events in season four with the Watchers, Duncan cuts off his friendship with him, but when Joe leaves the Watcher organization, so choosing Duncan as his friend instead of being a Watcher, they become close friends again. Joe continues to provide Duncan with a connection to the mortal world and although the Watchers remain an important part of the Mythology, this season there really weren’t any big Watchers stories.



Richie is grown into a man himself. Duncan is still his mentor, but it becomes clear that Richie is becoming an Immortal of his own, wants to make his own choices, while Duncan tries to help him from making the same mistakes he did. But Richie wants to live his own life, makes up his own mind but still wants to be friends with his former mentor. I really didn’t like that this season, like season four, Richie Ryan was absent for so many episodes. As he was becoming his own man, I would have liked to see him grow into that man and we did only get a fraction of that in the last two seasons, with not even half of the episodes where he was present. I was thankful though; there was a follow-up from the season four episodes where Duncan became evil and almost killed his protégé. I am also sad about what happened in the season five finale, not sure if that was necessary, but on the other hand, it fits with the shift we saw this season as I described above.

Final Word:

As I said, I think it is a strong season, it had only one real bad episode, one less than mediocre, but for the most part it was enjoyable. We did get a few episodes with Fitzcairn, which gave the much-needed humor. Like Roger Daltrey, Adrian Paul has such a talent for comedy, which we mainly see from moments in his past life, with his clumsiness, his funny accent. One more season to go and I know season six will not be of the same quality as the last three seasons because the format has changed a bit more if I am not mistaken. Less Adrian Paul, more try-outs for new leads for the follow-up show which ultimately became Highlander: The Raven, with Amanda as the lead immortal.



Highlander Season Five Rewatch Comments Grades Docx

Word – 47,1 KB 9 downloads

I've added the word document with the episode ratings with descriptions and comments for the ones who are interested in this. Just be aware, it is a draft document, sometimes also can be confusing because of grammar errors and some sloppiness.



Add comment

Comments

There are no comments yet.

Create Your Own Website With JouwWeb